Library
Who Will Fight For Intellectual Freedom Now?
Submitted by dochoc on Sat, 02/18/2006 - 15:25
(Read DocHoc's latest commentary, "Say 'no' to Oklahoma theocracy" in OKC's most provocative publication, the Oklahoma Gazette.)
Library Commission Supports Religious Zealot
Local library officials can spin it how they want but their recent action to create special parenting sections for certain targeted children’s books violates the spirit of intellectual freedom.

In a stark act of anti-intellectualism, the Oklahoma County Metropolitan Library Commission voted Thursday to reshelf so-called “controversial” children’s books so, well, so children cannot find them and read them
This all started last year when State Rep. Sally Kern (R-Oklahoma City) threatened to pull funding to our local library system if the libraries did not reshelf children’s books with non-sexual, age-appropriate gay themes. These books are King & King, Daddy's Roommate, The Duke Who Outlawed Jelly Beans and Heather Has Two Mommies. Supposedly the local religious zealot was acting, at least partially, on a patron’s complaint.
The commission then decided, perhaps fearing a lawsuit if they just targeted the gay-themed book, to reshelf not just those books but even more children books dealing with the realities of life, such as domestic abuse and alcoholism. These new parenting sections will be created in all of the system’s seventeen libraries. The realistic books will be placed on high shelves out of the reach of children.
Essentially, the commission wants to ensure that our children here do NOT have an understanding of the world around them. Their philosophy must be that if we keep our kids stupid and narrow-minded, they will be successful and happy. I guess we have to keep them that way if we want them to stay here.
The library formerly had more than adequate controls over allowing children access to library material. Parents could easily choose what they wanted their children to read. And, oh yeah, the Oklahoma religious freaks who want to dictate all the laws and rules in our state could also actually go to the library with their children, but, hey, that would probably be asking too much of them.
This action was not a compromise as some members of the commission tried to spin it in local news accounts. It was a direct attack on intellectualism, open-mindedness, and free thinking. It was a complete capitulation to the whims of a religious zealot on a personal crusade to generate hate against gay people.
Taking realistic, age-appropriate books away from children is immoral and anyone who somehow participated in this act without speaking up is just as responsible, just as immoral, as the religious zealot who initiated it.
Recently, longtime library director Lee Brawner passed away. A tireless champion for intellectual freedom, Brawner fought for the intellectual integrity of his libraries in a metropolitan area still held back by religious extremism and ignorance. I wonder what he would think about this decision? Who is fighting now for intellectual freedom in Oklahoma? Who at your local library cares now about intellectual freedom?
I am telling you, folks, theocracy looms here on the prairie. Do you think the fundies are going to call it “theocracy”? No, its name Thursday afternoon in Oklahoma City was “compromise.”
The Rich Person’s Stealing Bill of Rights (RIPSBOR)
“ . . . TABOR’s strict and rigid spending limits forced deep reductions to Colorado’s basic services, including public schools, colleges, roads, and health care, and kept the state from emerging from its budget crisis. TABOR’s negative effects led Coloradoans, on November 1st, 2005, to approve a statewide measure to suspend TABOR for five years.”—Alliance For Oklahoma’s Future
I am still perplexed that more state leaders have not come out against TABOR, the so-called Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights measure, which, if approved by voters, would decimate the Oklahoma economy and its educational systems.
Why it is particularly important state leaders speak up is because those who support TABOR (SQ 726) lie consistently about its impact in Colorado. Even many of those operatives who gathered signatures to place the measure on the ballot could not or would not tell the truth about TABOR. The petition drive was paid for by out-of-state money.
(I talked to one young woman who signed the petition and then later tried to withdraw it when she found out TABOR benefited rich people and would gut education. State officials told her she could NOT withdraw her signature.)
TABOR would constitutionally tie the state’s budget to a formula tied to population growth and the inflation rate. Any leftover money would have to be refunded to taxpayers. The richest among us would benefit the most, of course, and the rest of us would get underfunded schools, increased college tuition, skyrocketing health care costs, and dilapidated roads and bridges.
Colorado, the only state in the nation to adopt TABOR, had to rescind it recently because it had turned that state into, well, into a place like Oklahoma.
How can state leaders—Democrat or Republican—allow this measure to get through when Oklahoma struggles with some of the lowest educational funding rates in the entire nation?
It is disgusting that ultra-conservative, out-of-state elites have paid to get this measure on the ballot here to ensure rich people increase their wealth while the middle-class faces stagnant wages and increasing living costs.
As I have argued before, the state’s voters face huge decisions about the hypocritical, gubernatorial candidate Ernest Istook, TABOR, and religious encroachment into government through intelligent design and other bills this election year. If we “win” this soul-destroying trifecta, the state will suffer economically for years to come.
When did “family values” come to mean providing an underfunded education for children, making sure senior citizens cannot get health care, forcing college students to pay exorbitant college tuition, and making sure students do not learn established scientific methods.?
Check out the TABOR information on the Alliance For Oklahoma’s Future site.
- dochoc's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Shut Out of the Library
Submitted by dochoc on Wed, 05/11/2005 - 01:00I was shut out of the Oklahoma County Metropolitan Library Commission meeting today. This was after I told a library staff member that I was the author of this blog, Okie Funk: Notes From The Outback, and that I was under contract to write editorial commentary for a local publication.
Rest assured, The Daily Oklahoman and its partner, News 9, had access to the meeting. So we will all get the right-wing view for sure on this issue just like we always do.
This is what happened. I showed up at today’s meeting because I had planned to write about the King & King controversy. King & King is the gay-themed children’s book that prompted the state House of Representatives to pass a resolution to restrict children’s access to such books.
It is a marvelous book, and it teaches tolerance and acceptance.
I think the Oklahoma House was wrong to pass the resolution, of course. I think the book should remain on the library’s shelves in the children’s section and that parents should individually monitor their own children’s reading selections if they are concerned. There are methods to prevent your children from checking out books you do not want them to read. I also support the library’s Executive Director Donna Morris, who has said library collections should reflect the diversity in the community. I worry about politicians dictating what gets on the library shelves.
In addition, I think the state House of Representatives’ resolution was a hateful, anti-gay measure that allowed politicians to get some mileage out of a cultural wedge issue.
The commission was supposed to talk about these issues today. I took time out of my day to go to the meeting to maybe offer an alternative view in writing to the issue.
I arrived at the meeting fifteen minutes early. The meeting was packed, and there were no chairs left. I made the wrong assumption that I would be able to stand in the back of the room during the meeting, so I did not approach a staffer until after the meeting started.
Once the meeting started, I, along with at least seventeen other people (I counted), were denied access to the room. We were told that the “Fire Marshall” code prohibited us from entering the room. At that point, I thought I might be able to squeeze between a pillar and a wall, stick my head out, and hear what was going on. No such luck.
I then took a library staffer aside and explained my dilemma. I introduced myself, told him about my academic background, Okie Funk, and the other publication. But, again, he denied me access. I told him that the commission should have arranged to have the meeting in a larger room, and that I was going to write about it.
So, essentially, here we have a meeting about freedom of expression, and the meeting denies people freedom of expression.
What’s more we have a clear-cut case of a major bias against bloggers. Can you imagine someone at the library telling an Oklahoman reporter she could not attend a public meeting? There would be a lawsuit filed the next day.
I absolutely do NOT want to exaggerate the importance of this bog or myself. I have been marginalized like this and treated poorly by the power structure in this state for years and years in Oklahoma, and I expect it will happen again, no matter how many hits Okie Funks gets. So what? Undoubtedly, much of the power structure in the state probably does not even know what a blog is, right? I am not trying to make a federal case over this issue.
But most Oklahomans only hear the right-wing take on events in the state. Liberal bloggers offer an alternative view to the conservative Oklahoma media. What’s wrong with that? Why is the library, of all places, not blog friendly?
- dochoc's blog
- Login or register to post comments







Recent comments
6 days 10 hours ago
2 weeks 5 days ago
3 weeks 2 hours ago
11 weeks 6 days ago
24 weeks 4 days ago
25 weeks 2 days ago
30 weeks 3 days ago
40 weeks 2 days ago
44 weeks 3 days ago
52 weeks 16 hours ago